How libraries in Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and other Pennsylvania communities evolved from subscription clubs to vital public institutions

A library historian traces Pennsylvania's outsized role in American libraries, starting with Benjamin Franklin's 1731 Library Company of Philadelphia, the nation's first successful circulating library, which required a paid subscription rather than the free access we now associate with libraries. Andrew Carnegie gets credit for funding library buildings, but Pennsylvanians like Thomas Struthers were building library spaces, if less successfully, before him, and Carnegie's real innovation was forcing towns to pay ongoing operating costs themselves.

The piece also surfaces uglier history: a 1969 account from librarian-turned-councilwoman Augusta Clark describing white librarians' 'pained tolerance' of Black children in Philadelphia, plus a documented pattern of disability-access requests, including one civil rights complaint that was investigated and dismissed. State and federal funding acts through the 20th century gradually extended library support to urban and underserved communities that earlier laws had explicitly excluded.

The full dispatch is available from the source below.